washington, dc

The Democratic Strategist

Political Strategy for a Permanent Democratic Majority

Teixeira: The Common Good – An Idea So Crazy It Just Might Work!

The following article by Ruy Teixeira, author of The Optimistic Leftist and other works of political analysis, is cross-posted from his blog:

John Halpin explains in his latest at The Liberal Patriot:

“Is it any wonder that the Democratic Party’s brand is in the toilet these days? Voters don’t have a clue what Democrats are talking about half the time but sense that it has little to do with them or their values.

Much of modern progressive-left discourse sounds like a dreary small group discussion in sociology class. “Systemic problem this” and “structural change that” with no clarity whatsoever about what is being discussed, why it matters, and why anyone should care. Contemporary progressive language often seems designed to alienate and confuse people rather than find shared priorities and connections across disparate groups….

According to Pew’s data, Americans draw ideas about what is right and wrong in the world from several sources—religion among them for one-third of Americans, along with common sense (45 percent), philosophy (11 percent), and science (9 percent).

American values rightly emerge from a nice blend of all these sources.

But rather than listen to another strange Democratic speech on systemic inequality or a 10-point plan about a complicated new social policy that few people understand, it would be nice occasionally if religious Democrats just said: “We believe everyone is equal in the eyes of God and under our Constitution. Our policies are motivated by a desire to secure the common good for the entire nation and equal dignity and rights for all people.”

What would a Democratic politics motivated by concern for the common good look like? As Ruy Teixeira and I outlined way back in 2006 in a report for The American Prospect entitled, “The Politics of Definition”:

“Securing the common good means putting the public interest above narrow self-interest and group demands; working to achieve social and economic conditions that benefit everyone; promoting a personal, governmental and corporate ethic of responsibility and service to others; creating a more open and honest governmental structure that relies upon an engaged and participatory citizenry; and doing more to meet our common responsibilities to aid the disadvantaged, protect our natural resources, and provide opportunities rather than burdens for future generations…

A primary goal of the government in this approach is to ensure basic fairness and opportunity: the civil, legal, and economic arrangements necessary to ensure every American has a real shot at his or her dreams. Common-good progressivism does not guarantee that everybody will be the same, think the same, or get the same material benefits in life; it simply means that people should start from a level playing field and have a reasonable chance at achieving success.

Internationally, common-good progressivism focuses on new and revitalized global leadership grounded in the integrated use of military, economic, and diplomatic power; the just use of force; global engagement; new institutions and networks to deal with intractable problems; and global equity. As in past battles against fascism and totalitarianism, common-good progressives today seek to fight global extremism by using a comprehensive national-security strategy that employs all our strengths for strategic and moral advantage. This requires true leadership and global cooperation rather than the dominant “my-way-or-the-highway” mentality…

Progressives should not forget that the common good is a powerful theme in the social teachings of many major faith traditions—Catholicism and mainline Protestantism, in particular, and in moderate evangelical and other denominations as well. The principle of the common good is drawn upon in these faiths to guide people towards more thoughtful consideration of their own actions in light of others; to compel political leaders and policymakers to consider the needs of the entire society; and to check unrestrained individualism that frequently erodes community sensibilities and values.

The goal of the common good in both the secular and faith traditions is a more balanced and considerate populace that seeks to provide the social and economic conditions necessary for all people to lead meaningful and dignified lives.”

These common good values, in turn, underlie Democrats’ efforts to advance affordable health care, support for the poor, family and environmental policies, and public investments. If Democrats lead with consensus values like these—religious or otherwise—then specific policies and messages will flow more naturally and persuasively for voters.”

The common good: it was a great idea then, it’s an even better idea now!

4 comments on “Teixeira: The Common Good – An Idea So Crazy It Just Might Work!

  1. Candace on

    “Systemic problem this” and “structural change that” with no clarity whatsoever about what is being discussed, why it matters, and why anyone should care”

    And the solution is to clarify what is being discussed, why it matters and why they should care, right? I mean that’s an easy one.

    “rather than listen to another strange Democratic speech on systemic inequality or a 10-point plan about a complicated new social policy that few people understand, it would be nice occasionally if religious Democrats just said: “We believe everyone is equal in the eyes of God and under our Constitution.”

    I guess not! Like the republicans, the progressives need to realize that Americans are too stupid to understand whats actually going on? Democrats, or I guess only progressives for some reason, should use religious messaging to manipulate voters just like the republicans? It wont be long before that advice turns into why lying to voters is acceptable just like with the R’s.. but for democrats it will be encased in some cotton candy fluff about how American’s lives are too hard to be bothered by the unpleasantries of reality.

    “Is it any wonder that the Democratic Party’s brand is in the toilet these days?

    You can most recently thank Manchin and Sinema for that.
    In general thank the so called centrists. They have the money and power in the democratic party and they believe that progressives are a threat to the United States and the republican party is not. You don’t need to be a progressive or a minority to know how outrageous that is.
    No alternate reality pushing about progressives will hide that “centrists” have joined forces with the republicans to tear this country down and continually attack the democrats including Biden, BBB and brand always preaching defeat and division within the party while being silent/easy on the republicans.
    The recent Texeira posts here are good examples of how “centrists” along with republicans want to bring back for ’22 and ’24 some version of the 2016 mantra designed for progressive candidates and voters that democrats are the lesser evil to the republicans so why not vote or join a 3rd party? But “centrists” are the ones who should leave. Americans do not need their saccharin sweet presentation of gop help, messaging and governing and they aren’t going to vote for it D or R.

    Reply
  2. pjcamp on

    “Progressives should not forget that the common good is a powerful theme in the social teachings of many major faith traditions”

    That doesn’t mean they believe it. Evangelical Christians have managed to pretty much divorce their beliefs from the teachings of Jesus, and much of the Catholic hierarchy is following them.

    Reply
  3. sally bould on

    Please do not single out Sociology classes. This problem is not limited to Sociology and much Sociology is not to blame. Check out Sociology of Religion, for example.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.