washington, dc

The Democratic Strategist

Political Strategy for a Permanent Democratic Majority

LA Times Poll: Bush Ahead by 4 As Debates Begin

Bush leads Kerry 49-45 percent of nation-wide RV’s, with 6 percent undecided, according to a Los Angeles Times Poll conducted 9/25-28.

9 comments on “LA Times Poll: Bush Ahead by 4 As Debates Begin

  1. quixote http://acid-test.blogspot.com/ on

    Does anyone know *why* Gallup, and now even the LA Times, are weighting toward Republicans? There is no statistical methodology that I know of that can justify it, since the new weightings don’t reflect recent history. Do they say they have some reason to expect more Republicans than Democrats to turn out this election? If so, why?

    Reply
  2. Smooth Jazz on

    Ramdan,
    That was a well thought out rebuttal to my post. I will not counter rebuttal point by point; however, I do see a trend in the polls:
    Almost all of the major, mainstream polls – WP/ABC, Gallup, AP, NY Times, Pew, LA Times, CBS, among others – show GWB polling at or above 50% and beating Kerry by margins in the 6-8 point range; while other polls including Economist, ARG & Harris show the race to be much closer.
    Though I’ve see many reasons (ie party IDs mix, cell phones not covered, etc.) why this disparity exists, I honestly do not know why erstwhile reputable polls differ so much. I refuse to believe however that entities such as CBS, WP/ABC, NY Times, AP & Pew which have historially leaned Dem, to be all in the tank for GWB – And will jimmy their polls in a way that’s favorable to him; I just don’t buy that.
    All I can say is that the race will be close, and, as many here have rightfully said, it will come down to turnout – Provided there is no blatant fraud by either side.
    Best Regards,
    SJ

    Reply
  3. Smooth Jazz on

    Jody,
    You make some excellent points. As far as I know, RCP only leaves out Zogby Interactive; They do in fact include Zogby’s phone poll. Their view on Zogby Interactive is that insofar as Zogby subscribers tend to be overwhelmingly Dem, RCP believes Zogby’s subscriber poll is biased towards Kerry. I believe they leave out the UK based Economist poll for the same rationale.
    They also calculate their averages based on LVs only, even though they do have WITH and WITHOUT Nader numbers. The one potential issue is that they do not include RVs in their averages, ostensibly because the number of permutations & combinations are so many, most visitors to their site would be overwhelmed. They do include the RVs polls in the links on their site; They just do not include it in their RCP averages.
    At the same time, they do include all other close polls cited her recently: ARG, IBD, Rasmussen & Harris. They just use LV figures.
    http://www.realclearpolitics.com/index.html

    Reply
  4. Alan R. on

    The LA Times poll would show a tie if weighted to the party composition in the 2000 exit polls. The poll’s internals are at:
    http://www.latimes.com/media/acrobat/2004-09/14455239.pdf
    Bush gets 7% of Democratic support (multiplied by the D weight of .39 = 2.73), 94% of Republican support (multiplied by the R weight of .35 = 32.9), and 50% of Independents (multiplied by the I weight of .26 = 13), for a grand total of 48.63.
    Kerry gets 90% of D support (x .39 = 35.1), 4% of R support (x .35 = 1.4), and 45% of I support (x .26 = 11.7), for a grand total of 48.20.
    This jibes well with Rasmussen’s latest reading, Bush up 48-46.
    “Smooth Jazz” makes a valid point that Ruy may have shown some tendency in the past to be more accepting of pro-Democratic discrepancies from 2000 turnout figures than of pro-Republican discrepancies. However, that has no bearing whatsoever on the question of whether 2004 turnout will reproduce 2000 and 1996.
    This election is going to come down to the turnout, folks.

    Reply
  5. Marcus Lindroos on

    Regarding the debates, TNR’s Josh Benson offers some excellent advice ( http://www.tnr.com/doc.mhtml?i=express&s=benson093004 ). If there is an opening, Kerry should bend or even break the rules by asking “Shrub” direct, uncomfortable questions! As you know, there will be no rebuttals or follow-up questions because the Republicans are afraid their unraveling Iraq policy in particular would be challenged. But this doesn’t prevent Kerry from at least asking rhetorical questions that put the President in an uncomfortable light. Benson offers a few examples:
    “Mr. President, Iraq is on the verge of civil war. Entire towns are under the control of terrorists. A thousand American soldiers are dead. Yet you say peace and freedom are on the march. How do you explain this?”
    If either Bush or the moderator challenges Kerry for breaking the rules, a handy line would turn the tables right back: “This isn’t about rules,” Kerry could say. “It’s about the right of our soldiers’ families to have answers.” “If Bush can’t handle a simple question, how can he handle Al Qaeda?”
    Benson:
    “With some tact, this could be a major theme of the evening: Bush’s woeful and continued refusal to confront reality in the Middle East. It certainly fits with other aspects of his presidency: the lack of press conferences; his initial refusal to meet with the 9/11 Commission, and then only with Dick Cheney in tow; ignoring foreign leaders who don’t say what he wants to hear. Plainly, this is a president hiding from the world. It’s about time Kerry called him on it–rules be damned.”

    Reply
  6. Jody on

    Hey All,
    I believe we all read the polls the way we need to read them to find comfort. That is true for Republicans and Democrats. I read Rasmussen with a clear understanding of the potential bias.
    Early on in the process I decided I would rely on three/four polls and stick with them – through the ups and downs. I also read the editorial pages of several papers everyday (split between liberal and conservative – north/south -east/west). I try for balance. In so doing, there are good days and bad days. Overall, the presidential race remains very close.
    The areas that that are most hearening are voter registration and “get out the vote” efforts. It is those two areas that I believe will pay the biggest dividends and do not necessarily factor into the current polling trends.
    Efforts by Republicans to prevent voters from registering are in line with expectations. One only needs to harken back to Richard Nixon and his “dirty tricks” to understand the mentality of some partisans.
    Also of note is MSNBC dismissing Frank Lutz before he has a chance to do a post debate spin with *undecideds* tonight.
    After all my reflections I do have a question – how come REALCLEAR is so selective in the Polls used to compute their data?
    Jody

    Reply
  7. Smooth Jazz on

    Here’s what I don’t understand about your commentary: You consistently view ALL polls in scenarios favorable to Kerry. To wit:
    You use RVs as your benchmark, implicitly assuming that everyone who is registered will vote, giving Dems the advantage in almost all RV versus LV comparison. Perhaps most important, you invariably leave Nader out out your comparisons, ignoring the fact that Nader is on the ballot in 32 states, including the important battleground states of FLA, PA, NM & WIS.
    When Nader is included in the LA Times poll, GWB leads Kerry 51-45.
    I also see little or no comment on President Bush’s job approval ratings. Excluding Zogby subscriber polls, GWB job approval is in the 52%-56% range, over the critical 50% threshold for incumbents.
    A final note: 4 months ago when the Pro-Kerry LA Times had Kerry leading GWB by 8-9 points, you justified Kerry’s lead and the overwhelming Dem party ID advantage (6%) in that poll as a true microcosm of the electorate. Now you constantly spin current polls with Rep party ID advantages as frauds, ignoring Gov Arnold’s call to Rep arms during the Repub convention and that the war and terror impact on tilting the country more Repub.
    I don’t get it!!!

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.